ARCHIVE https://www.reddit.com/r/hogwartsshared/comments/success-managed-to-bring-a-non-fan-into-the-hogwarts-realm/ Aug 10, 2011
👽
reddit
the front page of the internet
reddit.com › r/hogwartsshared › comments
78

SUCCESS! Managed to bring a non-fan into the Hogwarts realm

submitted by to r/hogwartsshared

My partner has never read Harry Potter (I know, I know) but has been supportive of my shared dreaming practice. Last night we attempted synchronized entry and it WORKED.

They described:

  • "A castle that felt like a school but wrong somehow"
  • "People in robes that looked like uniforms"
  • "Moving stairs that made me nauseous"
  • "A feeling of being somewhere both familiar and impossible"

The interesting part: they saw architectural details that match my descriptions but interpreted them completely differently. The "Great Hall" became "a dining room with a sky ceiling that must be some kind of projection technology." The house points system became "a competitive school ranking system with magic display boards."

They've never read the books or seen the movies, so they don't have the cultural framework to interpret what they're seeing. But they're definitely seeing the same underlying structure I am.

This feels like strong evidence that the realm exists independently of fan knowledge, even if fan knowledge shapes how we interpret and describe it.

1 comments share save hide report
all 1 comments
sorted by: best top new controversial old
45 points

This is huge! If people without cultural context can access the same realm, that suggests it's not just elaborate collaborative fantasy roleplay. There might be something actually persistent there that we're all accessing through our individual interpretive frameworks.

34 points

I'm jealous! I've been trying to bring my non-fan sister for months but she's only managed to access generic "school dream" spaces, not the specific Hogwarts construct. What synchronization technique did you use?

23 points

We did the standard breathing synchronization (5 breaths per minute for 30 minutes) but added what I call "context bridging" - I described my entry pathway into the realm in detail while we synchronized, almost like giving directions to a shared mental space.

12 points

Or your partner is just having normal dreams influenced by your constant Harry Potter talk and you're interpreting coincidence as confirmation. Occam's razor, people.

community for X years